A visa can be cancelled on character grounds many years after a sentence has been served. A decision of the Administrative Review Tribunal on 2 November 2026 shows how the Tribunal weighs old but serious offending against a long life in Australia.
In Moulana and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration) [2026] ARTA 2707, Senior Member Dragovic set aside the cancellation of a Resident Return visa. The Tribunal applied Ministerial Direction 123A. This article explains what the Tribunal found and why.
The background
- The applicant is a 56 year old citizen of Sri Lanka. He arrived in Australia in December 1995.
- Over about seven weeks in 2008 he deposited cash for a syndicate at bank branches. The second count alone involved more than $3.2 million.
- In June 2013 the County Court of Victoria sentenced him to 26 months in prison on two counts of possessing property reasonably suspected of being proceeds of crime.
- He was released in late 2014 and has not offended in a similar way since.
- He was first told in October 2019 that cancellation was being considered. His Resident Return visa (subclass 155) was cancelled under section 501(2) in March 2025.
- He received the cancellation notice in August 2026, sought review within days and was detained in September 2026.
It was not in dispute that he failed the character test. A sentence of 12 months or more is a substantial criminal record. The only question was whether the visa should be cancelled anyway.
Which Direction applied
The parties prepared the case under Direction 123, which commenced on 31 October 2026. On the second day of the hearing it emerged that the Minister had signed Direction 123A on 16 October 2026. The Tribunal gave the parties another day. Both sides said the changes made no difference to this case, and the Tribunal applied Direction 123A. Our guide to Direction 123 explains the framework.
How the Tribunal weighed the case
| Consideration | What the Tribunal found | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Protection of the community | The money laundering was serious, but at the lower end of serious. The risk of similar offending was very low. Further traffic offences were likely | Limited, against him |
| Family violence | One incident in 2005, resolved by a diversion program with no conviction, and nothing since | Very limited, against him |
| Expectations of the community | Serious one off offending, with drug use and driving offences adding concern | Moderate, against him |
| Best interests of minor children | Two Australian citizen grandchildren, aged 9 and 2, whose father lives overseas | Substantial, in his favour |
| Ties to Australia | About 30 years in Australia and a close extended family | Substantial, in his favour |
| Legal consequences | He would stay in detention until removal | Minimal, in his favour |
| Impediments if removed | Serious mental illness would make housing and work difficult | Moderate, in his favour |
The Tribunal set aside the decision and decided that the visa not be cancelled.
What carried the case
Twelve years without similar offending, under pressure
After his release he lived with serious mental illness, the end of his marriage, unemployment, a failed business and a relapse into drug use. He did not return to financial crime. The Tribunal called that a powerful argument. Hardship is when people are most likely to reoffend, and he had not.
A family that knew the problem and stepped up
His sister and daughter gave evidence. They spoke plainly about his mental illness and what they do to keep him on treatment. The Tribunal treated the family’s awareness and closeness as a strong protective factor.
The grandchildren
His daughter is raising two children in Australia while her husband lives in Kuwait and cannot get a visa. The Tribunal accepted that the applicant was the main father figure for the older child, and gave the children’s interests substantial weight.
Two rulings on procedure
Written statements were not marked down
The Minister argued that statements from witnesses who did not give oral evidence deserved less weight, because they were not cross examined. The Tribunal disagreed. The Minister had not asked for those witnesses to attend. If the Minister wants to test a statement, it is for the Minister to say so.
Undeclared offences still counted
The applicant had declared in 2023 that he had never committed any other offence. Records obtained by summons showed five driving offences and 45 demerit point entries, including a drug driving offence in February 2026. His lawyer argued the Minister should have filed a further statement of issues before relying on them. The Tribunal rejected that. He should have declared them, and he had the chance to respond at the hearing.
The Tribunal accepted that his memory was affected by illness and gave the false statement limited weight. That finding turned on his medical history. It should not be expected in an ordinary case.
What the case does not say
The Tribunal was direct about his weaknesses. Asked who the victim of his offending was, he answered that he was. The Tribunal found a complete lack of insight and treated it as a risk factor. It also discounted character references from people who did not know about his conviction or his drug use.
He succeeded despite those findings, not because of them. The case is not authority that old offending is ignored, or that grandchildren are enough. It shows that a long, tested period in the community and real family support can outweigh serious offending when the evidence is there.
Lessons for anyone facing cancellation
- Disclose everything. Traffic matters, diversion programs and incidents that did not lead to a conviction can all be found by summons.
- Tell referees the full story. A reference from someone who does not know about the offending carries less weight.
- Bring family who know the hard facts. Evidence from relatives who understand the illness or addiction, and have a plan, is worth more than praise.
- Show the years since release. Work, treatment and conduct during difficult periods are the best evidence of risk.
- Document the role with children. School runs, care and daily contact, described by the child’s parent, show what the child would lose.
For two other recent outcomes, see our articles on ZKDP and Wheatland, both decided under the earlier Direction 110.
Frequently asked questions
Can a visa be cancelled for an offence committed many years ago?
Yes. In Moulana the offending was in 2008, the sentence was in 2013 and the visa was cancelled in 2025. Section 501(2) has no time limit.
Which Ministerial Direction applied in Moulana?
Direction 123A, signed on 16 October 2026. The parties had prepared under Direction 123 and agreed the changes did not affect the case.
Do grandchildren count under the best interests of children consideration?
They can. The Tribunal gave substantial weight to the interests of two grandchildren because of the applicant’s real role in their lives.
Will the Tribunal give less weight to a written statement if the witness does not attend?
Not for that reason alone. In Moulana the Minister had not asked for the witnesses to attend, so the Tribunal would not reduce the weight of their statements.
Do traffic offences matter in a character case?
Yes. They are part of a person’s conduct, and failing to declare them can be treated as giving false information to the Department.
Sam Kanjo, Migration Lawyer, Skyline Migration Lawyers, Melbourne.
Sources: Moulana and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration) [2026] ARTA 2707, read on 13 November 2026, and MIA Notice 28 of 13 November 2026.
Facing a character cancellation?
Time limits in character matters are short. Call 03 8108 8748 or email info@skylinemigrationlawyers.com.au with the decision.
This article is general information only. It is not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the facts of each case. Please seek advice about your own circumstances before you act.