Skip to content Skip to footer

Too sick to attend a Tribunal hearing: what ILM25 says the Tribunal must consider

A Tribunal hearing is often the one chance a visa applicant has to tell their story in person. If the applicant does not attend, the Tribunal can dismiss the review without looking at the merits. So what happens when the reason for not attending is serious illness?

On 12 November 2026 the Federal Circuit and Family Court answered that question in ILM25 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FedCFamC2G 2229. Judge Skaros quashed two Tribunal decisions because the Tribunal had not engaged with the applicant’s own account of why she could not take part. This article explains the decision and what it means in practice.

What happened

  • The applicant is a 64 year old citizen of China. She applied for a protection visa in December 2020, and a delegate refused it in August 2021.
  • She applied for review the same day. The review waited almost four years for a hearing.
  • In July 2024 she was diagnosed with breast cancer. She had surgery, six months of chemotherapy that ended in January 2025, and then radiotherapy in February 2025.
  • On 5 May 2025 the Tribunal invited her to a hearing by video on 22 May 2025.
  • On 16 May she asked for a postponement. She described physical weakness, exhaustion, fatigue, nausea and cognitive fog, and gave the Tribunal a letter from her oncologist.
  • On 19 May, three days before the hearing, the Tribunal refused. It said the hearing would take no longer than one hour and that it could not delay the review indefinitely.
  • She did not attend. On 5 June 2025 the Tribunal dismissed the review under section 99 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024.
  • She applied for reinstatement on 1 July 2025. On 7 July the Tribunal refused and confirmed the dismissal. The visa refusal was then taken to be affirmed.

She represented herself in the Court, with an interpreter.

Where the Tribunal went wrong

The Tribunal tested her reasons against the oncologist’s letter. It found the letter did not mention her capacity to take part in a hearing, and it stopped there.

The Court identified three problems with that approach.

The letter was written for a different purpose

The letter was addressed to the Department. It said her treatment was not available in China and asked for her visa to be extended. It was never meant to address whether she could sit through a hearing. Its silence on that point was, in the Court’s word, unsurprising.

Her own account was evidence

The applicant had told the Tribunal, in her own words, how the treatment affected her. The Minister accepted in Court that this account was evidence the Tribunal had to consider. The Tribunal’s reasons did not mention the weakness, exhaustion, nausea or cognitive fog she described. A general acknowledgment of her “health challenges” was not enough. The Court said exhaustion and cognitive fog go to whether a person can take part meaningfully, and not merely whether they can join a video call.

“Indefinite delay” did not justify the refusal

The Tribunal relied on a two year period in the letter. That period was the expected length of her hormone therapy. It was not the length of any incapacity, and nothing before the Tribunal treated the two as the same. Reinstating the review would have let the Tribunal list a new hearing at a reasonable date and assess her capacity then.

The result

DecisionDateOutcome in the Court
Dismissal for not attending5 June 2025Quashed
Refusal to reinstate7 July 2025Quashed
The review itselfSent back to the Tribunal to be decided according to law

The Court found both decisions legally unreasonable, because they lacked an evident and intelligible justification. It also extended time for her challenge to the first decision, noting the delay was short and she had no lawyer.

What the case does not say

ILM25 does not mean that illness guarantees a postponement. The Court said the weight given to an applicant’s account is a matter for the Tribunal. It also accepted that the Tribunal had no duty to ask her when she would be well enough. The error was narrower. The Tribunal never evaluated what she had actually said.

The Tribunal’s wider point also stands. A review cannot be put off forever, and a request that gives no timeframe is harder to grant.

If illness may stop someone attending a hearing

  • Ask early and in writing. Her request was made six days before the hearing, and the Court noted it was her first.
  • Describe the effects in detail. Say what the condition does to concentration, memory, stamina and the ability to answer questions. That account is evidence.
  • Get medical evidence written for the purpose. A letter should address capacity to prepare for and take part in a hearing on the listed date. A letter written for something else may carry little weight.
  • Propose a timeframe. Give a date or period after which a hearing is realistic. It answers the concern about indefinite delay.
  • If the review is dismissed, apply for reinstatement quickly. There is a time limit. She applied within it, and that mattered.
  • Tell the Tribunal about language or technology problems before the hearing. The Tribunal noted she had not raised them earlier.

Two situations

A hearing is listed during treatment

A person part way through chemotherapy receives a hearing invitation. They should write to the Tribunal straight away, explain the effects of treatment in their own words, attach a doctor’s letter about capacity, and suggest when a hearing could go ahead.

The review has already been dismissed

A person missed the hearing and has a dismissal notice. The first step is a reinstatement application within the time allowed, with the full explanation. If the Tribunal refuses without dealing with that explanation, ILM25 shows the refusal may be open to challenge in court. The time limits for court review are short, so advice should be sought at once.

For other recent decisions on how the Tribunal must reason, see our article on three October 2026 decisions and our note on the letter the Tribunal promised and never sent. Our guide to the Administrative Review Tribunal explains how review works.

Frequently asked questions

Can the Tribunal dismiss a visa review if the applicant does not attend the hearing?

Yes. Under section 99 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 the Tribunal can dismiss a review when the applicant fails to appear. The applicant can then apply for reinstatement.

Does serious illness mean the Tribunal must postpone a hearing?

No. The Tribunal decides each request. ILM25 requires it to consider the reasons the applicant gives, including the applicant’s own account of how the illness affects them.

Is a doctor’s letter needed to postpone a Tribunal hearing?

Medical evidence helps most when it addresses capacity to take part in a hearing. In ILM25 the letter was written for another purpose, and the Tribunal gave it little weight.

What happened to the applicant in ILM25?

The Court quashed the dismissal and the refusal to reinstate. Her protection visa review went back to the Tribunal to be decided according to law.

Does ILM25 apply only to protection visa cases?

The case concerned a protection visa review. The reasoning is about how the Tribunal deals with a dismissal for not attending and a request to reinstate, which can arise in other migration reviews.

Sam Kanjo, Migration Lawyer, Skyline Migration Lawyers, Melbourne.

Sources: ILM25 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FedCFamC2G 2229, read in full on 13 November 2026, and MIA Notice 28 of 13 November 2026.

Worried about a Tribunal hearing or a dismissal?

Time limits are short at every step. Call 03 8108 8748 or email info@skylinemigrationlawyers.com.au with the Tribunal’s letter.

This article is general information only. It is not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the facts of each case. Please seek advice about your own circumstances before you act.