Most people assume a visa cancellation is only revoked where the Tribunal is satisfied the person will not offend again. A decision of the Administrative Review Tribunal on 27 October 2026 shows that is not the test. In ZKDP [2026] ARTA 2505, Deputy President Millar found a moderate risk of reoffending and still revoked the cancellation.
The case is worth reading for what outweighed that risk. It was one of the last decided under Ministerial Direction 110, which was replaced by Direction 123 on 31 October 2026. This article explains the decision and what has changed since. It is written from the Migration Institute of Australia’s summary in MIA Notice 25 of 30 October 2026. The decision itself was not publicly accessible when this article was written.
The background
- The applicant is a 27 year old citizen of Afghanistan of Hazara ethnicity. He arrived in Australia in 2013 on a Global Special Humanitarian visa.
- In May 2022 he was sentenced to 7 years and 6 months for supplying a large commercial quantity of drugs, as a courier.
- His visa was mandatorily cancelled under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act.
- In 2025 the Tribunal affirmed a decision not to revoke the cancellation.
- In April 2026 the Federal Court sent the case back. The Tribunal had not adequately considered the harm he feared if returned to Afghanistan.
- He has held a Bridging visa R since July 2025.
How the Tribunal weighed the case
| Consideration | What the Tribunal found | Direction |
|---|---|---|
| Protection of the community | A moderate risk of reoffending. The Tribunal was guarded about his rehabilitation, because he said he no longer needed drug rehabilitation and he faced new drug charges, which were not convictions | Moderate weight against revocation |
| Ties to Australia | He has lived in Australia since 2013 | In favour |
| Best interests of minor children | The interests of four minor siblings | In favour |
| Legal consequences of the decision | He would remain in Australia on the bridging visa, and removal to Afghanistan looked unlikely | Moderate weight in favour |
| Impediments if removed | The risks facing Hazara returnees from the West with no family in Afghanistan | Heavy weight in favour |
| Claims about removal to Nauru | Treated as speculative | No weight recorded in the summary |
The Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted a decision revoking the cancellation.
Three things that carried the case
The counterfactual question
The Tribunal applied what is known as the counterfactual approach, from an earlier case called DVRL. It asks what would actually happen if the cancellation stood. On the evidence, he would remain in Australia on a bridging visa, because removal to Afghanistan looked unlikely. On that basis the Tribunal gave the legal consequences of the decision moderate weight in his favour.
Country evidence about his own group
The heaviest factor in his favour was the evidence about Hazara returnees from Western countries who have no family in Afghanistan. General statements about a country are less persuasive than evidence about the specific group a person belongs to and the specific situation they would return to.
The earlier court win
The case only reached this point because the Federal Court found the first Tribunal decision had not properly considered the harm he feared. A review that goes wrong on a point of law can be corrected, and the second hearing can end differently.
What counted against him
The Tribunal did not gloss over the weaknesses. It was guarded about rehabilitation for two reasons: his statement that he no longer needed drug rehabilitation, and new drug charges. The Migration Institute’s summary draws the practical lesson that people in this position must follow through on rehabilitation referrals, because unanswered referrals and new charges are weighed against them.
What has changed since: Direction 123
ZKDP was decided under Direction 110. From 31 October 2026, Direction 123 applies to these decisions. Two of its changes bear directly on a case like this one.
- The strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia is no longer a primary consideration. It is now one of the other considerations.
- The risk threshold is lower. The question is whether the person might engage in further conduct, not whether they would.
The legal consequences of the decision and the impediments a person would face if removed remain considerations under the new Direction. How the Tribunal weighs a case like ZKDP under Direction 123 has yet to be seen. Our guide to Direction 123 sets out the changes in full.
Two situations
A person released from detention who cannot be removed
Evidence of what will really happen if the cancellation stands belongs in front of the Tribunal. In ZKDP, the fact that he would remain in Australia either way was given moderate weight in his favour.
A person whose home country is unsafe for their ethnic or religious group
Country information should be specific to the group and to the person’s circumstances, including whether they have family there. In ZKDP that evidence carried heavy weight.
Our article on three recent court decisions covers related rulings on legal consequences and third country removal.
Frequently asked questions
Can a visa cancellation be revoked if there is still a risk of reoffending?
Yes. In ZKDP the Tribunal found a moderate risk of reoffending and still revoked the cancellation, because other considerations outweighed it.
What weighed most in ZKDP’s favour?
The impediments he would face if removed, given the risks to Hazara returnees from the West with no family in Afghanistan. The Tribunal gave that heavy weight.
Was ZKDP decided under Direction 123?
No. It was decided on 27 October 2026 under Direction 110. Direction 123 commenced on 31 October 2026.
Do new charges count against a person if there is no conviction?
In ZKDP the Tribunal was guarded about his rehabilitation partly because of new drug charges, even though they were not convictions.
Sam Kanjo, Migration Lawyer, Skyline Migration Lawyers, Melbourne.
Sources: ZKDP [2026] ARTA 2505 as summarised in MIA Notice 25 of 30 October 2026.
Facing a character cancellation?
Time limits in character matters are short. Call 03 8108 8748 or email info@skylinemigrationlawyers.com.au with the decision.
This article is general information only. It is not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the facts of each case. Please seek advice about your own circumstances before you act.