Skip to content Skip to footer

Partner visa family violence claims: why the independent expert’s opinion is usually final (Bakshi, November 2026)

When a relationship ends before a partner visa is finalised, the visa normally ends with it. The family violence provisions are the main exception. They allow the visa to continue to be considered where the applicant suffered family violence at the hands of the sponsor.

A decision of the Federal Circuit and Family Court on 4 November 2026 shows how those claims are decided when the decision maker is not convinced, and why the evidence has to be right at one particular stage. The case is Bakshi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FedCFamC2G 2153, a decision of Judge Renwick.

This article is written from the Migration Institute of Australia’s summary in MIA Notice 27 of 6 November 2026. The judgment itself was not publicly accessible when this article was written.

How a family violence claim is decided

There are two routes. Where a court has made a relevant finding or order, that usually settles the question. Otherwise, the applicant relies on other evidence, such as statements, reports from doctors, psychologists or social workers, and police records.

On that second route, the decision maker first looks at the evidence. If the decision maker is satisfied that family violence occurred, the claim is accepted. If not, the claim is referred to an independent expert. Under the Migration Regulations, the decision maker must then take the expert’s opinion as correct.

That last step is the one that matters. Once the expert has given an opinion, neither the Department nor the Tribunal weighs the evidence again.

What happened in Bakshi

  • The applicant was granted a provisional partner visa in 2016 on the basis of his marriage.
  • In 2018 his sponsor withdrew her sponsorship and alleged violence by him. He claimed that she had committed family violence against him.
  • The Department’s delegate obtained an independent expert opinion. The expert rejected his claim.
  • At the Tribunal, a second independent expert was appointed with his agreement. She also rejected the claim, and the Tribunal took her opinion as correct.
  • He went to court with seven grounds of legal error.

What the Court decided

The lead argument was about order. The applicant said the Tribunal had to decide for itself that family violence had not occurred before it could refer the claim to an expert. He relied on an earlier 2026 decision, Kaur [2026] FedCFamC2G 1451. In Kaur, the Court had found legal error where the Tribunal referred a claim to an expert without meaningfully considering the evidence first.

Judge Renwick held that Kaur was a different case. The Tribunal does not need to state its lack of satisfaction before referring. Here, the applicant’s own representative had expressly agreed to the referral. The Tribunal’s reasons also showed that it had really considered the evidence.

Most of the remaining grounds asked the Court to re-examine how the expert had reasoned. The Court treated that as an invitation to review the merits, which a court on judicial review cannot do. An argument that the expert’s reasoning was illogical failed, because the points raised were not critical steps in her opinion.

The Court found no legal error. It dismissed the application and ordered the applicant to pay costs of $9,097.93.

Why the case matters

The Migration Institute’s summary draws the lesson directly. An independent expert’s opinion binds the decision maker unless the opinion itself is affected by legal error. An attack on how the expert weighed the evidence will probably fail.

In practice, that moves the decisive moment earlier than most applicants expect.

  • The strongest evidence should go in with the claim, so that the decision maker can be satisfied without a referral.
  • If a referral happens, everything the applicant relies on, and every objection, should be put to the expert directly. There is no later stage at which missing evidence can be weighed.
  • Agreeing to a referral has consequences. In Bakshi, the representative’s agreement was one reason the challenge failed.

Three situations

An applicant with a court order

A relevant court finding or order is the more certain route, because it does not depend on an expert’s opinion.

An applicant with statements and a psychologist’s report

This is the evidence route. The claim stands or falls on how complete and consistent that material is, first before the decision maker and then, if referred, before the expert. Reports should address what happened, when, and the effect on the applicant.

An applicant whose expert opinion was unfavourable

A court can set the decision aside only for legal error in the opinion or the process. Disagreement with the expert’s conclusion is not enough. The time limit for a court application is short, so the opinion and the decision should be reviewed straight away.

Our article on bridging visa rights during a partner visa application explains what visa a person holds while a claim is being decided.

Support

Anyone experiencing family violence can call 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 at any time. In an emergency, call 000. A person’s visa status does not prevent them from seeking help or protection.

Frequently asked questions

What are the family violence provisions?

They allow a partner visa application to continue to be considered after the relationship has ended, where the applicant suffered family violence committed by the sponsor.

Who decides whether family violence occurred?

The decision maker first. If the decision maker is not satisfied on the evidence, the claim is referred to an independent expert, and the expert’s opinion must be taken as correct.

Can the Tribunal disagree with the independent expert?

No. In Bakshi the Court confirmed that the opinion binds the decision maker unless it is affected by legal error.

Did the applicant in Bakshi succeed?

No. The Court found no legal error, dismissed the application and ordered costs of $9,097.93.

Sam Kanjo, Migration Lawyer, Skyline Migration Lawyers, Melbourne.

Sources: Bakshi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FedCFamC2G 2153, as summarised in MIA Notice 27 of 6 November 2026.

Has a relationship ended during a partner visa application?

We handle these matters privately and carefully. Call 03 8108 8748 or email info@skylinemigrationlawyers.com.au.

This article is general information only. It is not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the facts of each case. Please seek advice about your own circumstances before you act.